Ideas

From PyMOLWiki
Revision as of 20:59, 21 January 2010 by Lucajovine (talk | contribs) (Low-Level Enhancement Ideas (Mostly C-oriented))
Jump to: navigation, search

Ideas for PyMOL Development

This page was originally developed for the 2008 Google Summer of Code competition, but seeing as PyMOL wasn't selected, this page can instead serve as a resource for ongoing PyMOL development efforts.

Where to Start

Always start with Python and only delve down into the C code when absolutely necessary. Although PyMOL is mostly a C-based application, much of the that code is opaque, fragile, and unforgiving. Although C code refactoring is an important project goal, such work may not be ideal since once mistake could potentially to destabilize the entire platform.

Fortunately, the Python interpreter and the PyMOL command and selection languages make it possible to extend PyMOL safely and quickly. Even when performance is critical, Python should be the interface between external C, C++, and Java code and PyMOL's internal C data structures.

Choosing a Topic

The best open-source code is usually written by an end-users attempting to meet their own pressing needs. So if you have already have a specific need which relates to PyMOL, then we strongly encourage you to follow up on that first!

If you are looking for ideas, then try to seek out enhancements and/or integrations that will impact the largest potential user base. For example, imagine what new things might be useful to virtually all medicinal chemists, all structural biologists, all movie-makers, all paper-writers, and so forth.

The ideas below are organized by category. Right now, integration with other open-source projects seems like the approach most likely to yield significant benefit, so those ideas are first.

Integration Ideas (Linking Out to Useful Open-Source Tools)

In most cases, depending on the need, integration can be accomplished through standalone Python scripts, through new PyMOL commands, through PyMOL Wizards, or via Tkinter plugins.

  • APBS (electrostatics calculations): Improve the existing plugin. Michael Lerner is currently leading this effort. See APBS
yea (Tree Jedgold"Vcpmartin") / nay (0)
  • RDKit (cheminformatics, depiction, UFF cleanup, etc.): Lots of potential here, however C++ coding may be necessary for more advanced integration tasks. RDKit home
yea (Markvanraaij) / nay (0)
  • GIMP (image manipulation): Streamline & document the process of exporting images from PyMOL into GIMP and preparing them for submission to scientific Journals.
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Jmol (publishing visualizations inside of web pages): Liason between PyMOL & Jmol projects to develop a shared molecular visualization data model compatible with both applications.
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Firefox (plugin): Develop an PyMOL plugin compatible with Firefox.
yea (Vvostri) / nay (0)
  • MMTK (molecular mechanics -- Python/flexible): Develop the ability to round-trip molecular systems from PyMOL, into MMTK, and back.
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • GROMACS (molecular mechanics -- C/fast) - Maybe some ideas can be shared with this guy. Gromacs GUI
yea (Jedgold) / nay (0)
  • OpenOffice (escape Microsoft hegemony): Develop an PyMOL plugin.
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • IPython integration (interactive shell): a robust alternative to the PyMOL command line?
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • R (statistics): PyMOL a 3D viewer environment for visualizating & manipulating large statistical data sets?

Are there other key open-source packages we might specifically target for integration with PyMOL, either through GSoC or beyond?

High-Level Enhancement Ideas (Mostly Python-oriented)

yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Develop new plugins which automate routine tasks.
yea (Vvostri) / nay (0)
  • Improve the Python API documentation.
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Flesh out the new "from pymol2 import PyMOL" instance-based PyMOL API.
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Develop alternate Tkinter "skins" (for custom OEM-like applications).
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Develop a Tkinter/TOGL widget which holds a PyMOL viewer instance.
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Develop a PyQt widget which holds a PyMOL viewer instance.
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Create a plugin-manager GUI in the style of Firefox, Rythmbox, Gedit, Eclipse. A GUI where it is easy to turn off/on plugins, configure them and see help-contents for them. Maybe also some way to paste a url to install a new Plugin.
yea (Vvostri) / nay (0)
  • Add a plugin for a GUI window with the same functionality as the "Control Panel" window in SwissPDB Viewer.
yea (Vvostri) / nay (0)
  • Extend and modify the PyMOL command language so as to be compatible with existing RasMol and/or Jmol scripts.
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Enhance the Mutagenesis Wizard in order to support Nucleic acids and/or Sugars.
yea (Luca Jovine) / nay (0)

Low-Level Enhancement Ideas (Mostly C-oriented)

  • Enable editing of displayed sequence alignments.
yea (Jedgold, Aschreyer, Luca Jovine) / nay (0)
Would this then feed back to the structural alignment? Jedgold
  • Add multi-line textual annotations
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Support additional annotation object including: arrow, lines, and blobs.
yea (Aschreyer, Vvostri) / nay (0)
  • Add display of secondary structure into the sequence viewer.
yea (Luca Jovine) / nay (0)
  • Enable per-object Z clipping (especially in the ray tracer)
yea (Gregori) / nay (0)
I would go a step further with fully customizable selection-based clipping planes (XYZ, color and transparency) (Gregori)
  • Highlight H-bonds, salt bridges, Pi-stacking, Pi-cations, etc.
yea (Luca Jovine) / nay (0)
  • Build in a simple forcefield and energy minimizer suitable for use with Mutagenesis.
yea (Luca Jovine) / nay (0)
  • Incorporate a suite of standard NMR visualizations (restraint violations, per-residue RMS, etc.)
yea (Vvostri"Vcpmartin") / nay (0)
  • Enumeration and display of low-energy conformers.
yea (Jedgold) / nay (0)
This could be done by integrating RDKit, I think. Aschreyer
  • Automated structure grafting (poor-man's homology modeling).
yea (0) / nay (Jedgold)
Perhaps a plugin to Modeller instead? Jedgold
  • Import of alignment files.
yea (Jedgold) / nay (0)
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Add buttons for Set ChainID and Renumber Residues From... to Edit menu or Actions (wrapper around Alter command)
yea (Sheehanj) / nay (0)

Difficult C-level Code Refactoring Ideas

  • Assemble a test suite which thoroughly exercises the existing code (a prerequisite to major refactoring).
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Catch & handle memory-allocation failures gracefully (instead of crashing).
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Replace PyMOL's memory management & custom containers with a simple runtime object model.
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Separate the View and the Controllers from the Model so that they can all run asynchronously (on multiple cores).
yea (Vvostri) / nay (0)
  • Enable generalized undo of changes made to the Model.
yea (Vvostri"Vcpmartin") / nay (0)
  • Clean up the internal matrix handling code.
yea (0) / nay (0)

Ideas Involving Proprietary APIs

Since these involve closed-source APIs and infrastructure, they aren't suitable for open-source development efforts. However, such requests are noted here for the sake of complete coverage.

  • Create a Windows port with "native" look & feel. <- Could this be done in PyQT or PyGTK?. Then it would look "native", but be cross-platform and not proprietary.
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Integrate directly via Mathematica via MathLink.
yea (0) / nay (Aschreyer)
  • Further enhance JyMOL (Java-JNI/wrapped PyMOL)
yea (Tree) / nay (0)
  • Integrate with Matlab.
yea (0) / nay (Aschreyer)

More Ideas (Please add your own!)

  • MolViz is a project to incorporate head tracking input into PyMol. This is accomplished through a ImmersiveViz script written in Python to control the molecule's position using the existing PyMol API. Related projects would include:
    • Improving the existing ImmersiveViz PyMol plugin for more precise control of the environment.
    • Developing new input drivers for the Wiimote form of control. This would require some bluetooth hacking.
    • Implementing some other forms of input for head tracking, such as fisheye head tracking, IR webcam tracking, etc (refer to the end of this [video] for a better description).
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Provide a 2D chemical depiction of the current 3D view.
yea (Aschreyer) / nay (0)
RDKit?
  • Spreadsheet view with additional information (e.g. IC50's).
yea (Aschreyer) / nay (0)
  • Create additional documentation, screen casts, & tutorials.
yea (Markvanraaij) / nay (0)
  • Export 3D PDF images.
yea (Vvostri) / nay (0)
  • Add extra "Single Word Selectors" like "nucleic", "protein", "water", "ions", "backbone" (for nucleic acids or proteins), "mainchain", "sidechain"
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • Add functionality that allows you to select atoms based on their location (i.e. select (x_coordinate < 10) and (z_coordinate > 0))
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • set pdb_mirror option to use PDB mirrors other than RCSB for fetching structures (PDBe, PDBj); the EBI mirror is much faster from Europe for example.
yea (Aschreyer) / nay (0)
  • have the ability to link the TK console to the viewer so that users don't have to constantly alt+tab between what they want
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • have the ability to disable typing in the viewer and automatically type in the TK console (I like being able to cut/paste/home/end)
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • I see a lot of "can pymol do this" threads - any ideas of a good UI for a page of "things PyMOL can do?"
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • make an option where I can turn on a coordinate grid - perhaps an object that is a cuboid grid around any object in the view so I can still alter how it's rendered?
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • iPhone / Nexus One app(s)
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • single-color bonds between nonidentical or any spherical atoms colored specifically
yea (0) / nay (0)
  • double bonds as two parallel cylinders
yea (Vvostri) / nay (0)
  • export scenes as WebGL / Could make mobile apps, presentation plugins obsolete
yea (Aschreyer) / nay (0)
  • export images in vector format
yea (Vvostri) / nay (0)